Old Fashioned Pimento Cheese Recipe

Learn how to make a classic, Southern-style old fashioned pimento cheese recipe that’s creamy, tangy, and unforgettable.

Table of Contents

Pimento cheese is a beloved Southern staple, cherished for its versatility and delicious flavor. Whether used as a dip, spread, or sandwich filling, this recipe captures the essence of traditional Southern cooking. In this guide, you’ll discover the secrets to crafting the perfect old fashioned pimento cheese recipe.

What Is Pimento Cheese?

Pimento cheese is a creamy, cheesy blend of sharp cheddar, mayonnaise, and sweet pimentos. It’s a simple yet flavorful dish that has been a staple in Southern kitchens for generations.

A Brief History of Pimento Cheese

Pimento cheese’s origins date back to the early 20th century when pimentos became widely available in the U.S. Today, it’s celebrated as a versatile comfort food. For more historical context.

Why Pimento Cheese Stands Out

The appeal of pimento cheese lies in its simplicity and adaptability. With just a few ingredients, it transforms into a dish that can be customized endlessly. It’s suitable for casual gatherings or sophisticated hors d’oeuvres. The combination of tangy pimentos, creamy mayonnaise, and sharp cheddar creates a balanced flavor profile loved by many.

Ingredients for Old Fashioned Pimento Cheese Recipe

To make the perfect old fashioned pimento cheese recipe, you’ll need:

2 cups sharp cheddar cheese, grated (freshly grated works best)
1/2 cup mayonnaise (use a high-quality brand like Duke’s for authenticity)
1/4 cup cream cheese, softened
1/3 cup pimentos, diced (drained)
1 tsp garlic powder
1/2 tsp onion powder
1/4 tsp cayenne pepper (optional, for a slight kick)
Salt and black pepper, to taste

Ingredient Tips

Always use freshly grated cheese; pre-shredded cheese contains anti-caking agents that can affect texture.
Opt for jarred pimentos for convenience and authenticity.
Adjust the cayenne pepper to suit your spice preference.

For more tips on ingredient selection, visit this guide to cooking with cheese.

Optional Add-Ins

Looking to experiment? Try adding:

Chopped jalapeños for a spicy twist.
Crumbled bacon for added richness.
Finely diced green onions for a fresh bite.

Step-by-Step Instructions

Step1 : Prepare Your Ingredients

Grate the sharp cheddar cheese.
Drain and dice the pimentos.
Soften the cream cheese to make mixing easier.

Step2 : Combine the Ingredients

In a large mixing bowl, combine the grated cheddar, mayonnaise, and cream cheese.
Add the diced pimentos, garlic powder, onion powder, and cayenne pepper.
Mix well until all ingredients are evenly incorporated.

Step3 : Season to Taste

Add salt and black pepper, tasting as you go.
Adjust spices for your desired level of flavor.

Step4 : Chill Before Serving

Transfer the mixture to an airtight container.
Chill in the refrigerator for at least 2 hours. This allows the flavors to meld together.

Step5 : Final Touches

Before serving, give the mixture a quick stir and garnish with a sprinkle of paprika or parsley for presentation.

Serving Suggestions

Pimento cheese is incredibly versatile. Here are a few classic ways to enjoy it:

As a dip: Serve with crackers, celery sticks, or pretzels.
In sandwiches: Spread between slices of soft white bread.
As a topping: Add to burgers or baked potatoes for a creamy kick.
In recipes: Use as a filling for deviled eggs or stuffed jalapeños.

Creative Serving Ideas

Pimento Cheese Quesadillas: Spread pimento cheese between tortillas and toast until crispy.
Grilled Pimento Cheese Sandwiches: Use it as a filling for grilled cheese sandwiches.
Pimento Cheese Pasta Bake: Mix into cooked pasta, top with breadcrumbs, and bake until golden.

Pro Tip:

Pair your pimento cheese with a chilled glass of sweet tea for an authentic Southern experience.

Healthier Variations

For those looking to lighten the dish, consider these substitutions:

Use Greek yogurt instead of mayonnaise for a tangy, lower-calorie option.
Opt for reduced-fat cheese and cream cheese.
Add finely chopped vegetables like bell peppers or carrots for extra nutrition.

Pimento Cheese Across the U.S.

While pimento cheese is most popular in the South, its influence has spread nationwide. Variations can now be found in gourmet restaurants and upscale events. In New York, chefs are incorporating pimento cheese into artisanal dishes. In California, it’s being used in fusion recipes, blending Southern traditions with international flavors.

The Legacy of Pimento Cheese: A Deep Dive

The old fashioned pimento cheese recipe holds a unique place in Southern culinary tradition. Its versatility and rich history make it a dish worth celebrating. Let’s dive deeper into its cultural impact, modern interpretations, and why it continues to thrive in kitchens across the U.S.

Pimento Cheese: A Symbol of Southern Comfort

Pimento cheese transcends its simple ingredients to become a symbol of Southern comfort and hospitality. At family gatherings, church potlucks, and school lunches, pimento cheese is a reminder of home and shared memories. Its affordability and ease of preparation have made it accessible to everyone, regardless of economic background. In fact, during the Great Depression, pimento cheese became a dietary staple for many Southern families.

Evolving Flavors and Creative Twists

Although the classic recipe remains popular, chefs and home cooks alike have experimented with innovative versions of pimento cheese. Some incorporate specialty cheeses like smoked Gouda or pepper jack, while others blend in exotic ingredients such as sun-dried tomatoes or caramelized onions. These variations cater to changing tastes while maintaining the dish’s core identity. For instance:

Spicy Pimento Cheese: By adding jalapeños, hot sauce, or even diced habaneros, you can create a version that’s perfect for spice lovers.
Herbed Pimento Cheese: Fresh herbs like parsley, dill, or chives can enhance the flavor profile, adding a touch of sophistication.
Gourmet Pimento Cheese: Infusing the mixture with truffle oil or topping it with candied pecans elevates it to fine-dining status.

The Role of Pimento Cheese in Popular Culture

Pimento cheese’s cultural impact extends beyond the kitchen. It has become a defining feature of events like the Masters Golf Tournament in Augusta, Georgia, where patrons eagerly anticipate the famous pimento cheese sandwiches served on-site. This connection to sports and tradition has solidified its reputation as a quintessential Southern food.

Additionally, pimento cheese has found its way into cookbooks, television shows, and even social media trends, where food bloggers and influencers showcase creative ways to incorporate it into recipes. Whether it’s stuffed into fried green tomatoes or used as a topping for nachos, pimento cheese continues to inspire culinary innovation.

Nutrition and Dietary Considerations

While pimento cheese is undoubtedly indulgent, it can be adapted to fit various dietary needs. For those watching their calorie intake, swapping full-fat ingredients for lighter alternatives can make a significant difference. Additionally, pimento cheese is naturally gluten-free, making it suitable for those with gluten sensitivities.

Low-Carb Pimento Cheese: This dish is a favorite among keto dieters due to its high-fat content and low carbohydrate count.
Vegetarian-Friendly: As a meat-free dish, it’s an excellent source of protein for vegetarians when paired with fresh veggies or whole-grain crackers.

Pimento Cheese in the Modern Culinary Landscape

The resurgence of interest in traditional foods has brought pimento cheese back into the spotlight. Restaurants across the country are reinventing the dish, featuring it as a key ingredient in everything from gourmet burgers to artisan pizzas. The simplicity of pimento cheese allows chefs to experiment while preserving its nostalgic charm.

Moreover, the rise of farmer’s markets and local food movements has encouraged a return to homemade versions of pimento cheese. Consumers appreciate the authenticity and freshness that come from preparing it at home using high-quality ingredients. This trend not only supports local economies but also reinforces the connection between food and community.

Why Pimento Cheese Endures

At its core, pimento cheese endures because it represents more than just a recipe. It’s a testament to the ingenuity and resourcefulness of Southern cooks who transformed simple ingredients into something extraordinary. It’s a reminder of shared meals, cherished traditions, and the universal love of comfort food.

By adapting to changing tastes while staying true to its roots, pimento cheese remains a beloved dish that bridges generations and brings people together.

The Unique Texture and Flavor Science Behind Pimento Cheese

One of the standout features of the old fashioned pimento cheese recipe is its distinct texture and flavor profile. The science behind achieving the perfect consistency involves balancing moisture, fat, and flavor enhancers. Sharp cheddar cheese provides the robust and tangy backbone, while mayonnaise contributes creaminess and moisture that binds the mixture. Pimentos, with their sweet and slightly tangy flavor, create a bright contrast that complements the richness of the other ingredients.

The role of cream cheese is often underestimated. By softening it beforehand, you ensure it blends smoothly, creating a velvety texture that defines a well-made pimento cheese. Adjusting seasoning levels, such as adding garlic or onion powder, enhances the savory notes without overpowering the subtle sweetness of pimentos. Additionally, the optional cayenne pepper adds a gentle heat that lingers, giving the dish a satisfying complexity without overshadowing its classic appeal.

Another crucial element is the choice of cheddar cheese. Freshly grated sharp cheddar not only improves the flavor but also ensures a better consistency. Pre-shredded cheese often contains anti-caking agents that can hinder smooth blending. For those who prefer bolder flavors, experimenting with extra-sharp cheddar or mixing in smoked cheddar can create depth that elevates the traditional recipe.

Balancing Classic and Modern Techniques

Adapting this recipe for today’s preferences while respecting its roots involves combining traditional techniques with modern tools. For instance, using a food processor to blend ingredients can save time and achieve a uniform texture. However, many purists argue that manually mixing by hand preserves the rustic charm and authenticity of the dish. Regardless of your approach, the result should be a well-balanced spread that highlights the natural flavors of its components.

The interplay of texture is another essential aspect. When served as a dip, the smoothness of the pimento cheese contrasts beautifully with the crunch of crackers or vegetable sticks. In sandwiches, the spread’s creamy consistency pairs perfectly with soft bread, creating a harmonious bite. Whether it’s spread thinly as a light topping or piled generously in hearty sandwiches, the versatility of pimento cheese lies in its ability to adapt to various culinary applications.

Tips for Customizing Your Recipe

Customizing your pimento cheese can turn a classic recipe into a personal signature dish. Adding ingredients like roasted red peppers or sun-dried tomatoes introduces a smoky or umami-rich dimension. For those who enjoy tangy flavors, incorporating a dash of vinegar or a squeeze of fresh lemon juice can brighten the dish further. Experimenting with herbs such as dill, cilantro, or chives adds a fresh, aromatic touch that complements the cheese and pimentos.

For adventurous cooks, blending in non-traditional cheeses like blue cheese or goat cheese offers an unexpected twist. These variations not only diversify the flavor profile but also make the dish suitable for a wider range of occasions, from casual gatherings to elegant dinner parties. As you experiment, keep in mind the importance of balance—each ingredient should enhance rather than overpower the core flavors of cheddar, mayonnaise, and pimentos.

Frequently Asked Questions

How is pimento cheese made from scratch?

Making pimento cheese from scratch involves blending grated cheese, mayonnaise, and pimentos with spices. Follow the steps above for a foolproof method.

What are the ingredients in Chick-fil-A pimento cheese?

Chick-fil-A’s version uses a blend of cheddar cheese, mayonnaise, and pimentos, with subtle spices for added flavor. Learn more about their recipe variations here.

What is the difference between palmetto cheese and pimento cheese?

Palmetto cheese is a branded version of pimento cheese, often containing additional spices and creamier textures.

How do Southerners eat pimento cheese?

Southerners enjoy pimento cheese as a dip, spread, or even baked into casseroles. Its versatility makes it a favorite.

Conclusion

The old fashioned pimento cheese recipe is more than just a dish; it’s a tradition that embodies the essence of Southern hospitality. With its rich history, customizable flavor profile, and endless versatility, pimento cheese continues to hold a special place on tables across the country. Whether you’re hosting a party, preparing a quick snack, or sharing a meal with loved ones, this recipe offers a delicious reminder of the comfort and joy that food can bring.